The Counterflow Heat Exchanger

Reference notes for moving heat from one pipe stream to another without mixing them: feed-water heaters, coolers, economizers, reheaters.

What it does

The exchanger has two sides, A and B. Each side is its own pipe path through the block. The fluids never mix: only heat crosses, from the hotter side to the colder. Either side may hold water, steam, air or exhaust gas, and steam may condense or water boil inside it.

Ports and flow directions

Both sides have a port on each end face (the faces along the way it was placed):

Counterflow is the point of the device: the two streams run in opposite directions.

The ports at the two ends look the same, so nothing stops you piping it the wrong way round. Walk along it before you open the valves: the hot stream's inlet and the cold stream's outlet should be at the same end.

Block layout, seen from above (front to the east):

        back (west)                                  front (east)
 A in  ---->  [ HX ][ HX ][ HX ][ HX ]  ---->  A out   (hot stream)
 B out <----  [ HX ][ HX ][ HX ][ HX ]  <----  B in    (cold stream)
              (2 x 2 x 4: two more rows on top)

Both streams must flow. A side with no way out fills, warms up to the other side's temperature, and then takes almost nothing.

What to expect

From GameTests (EA 26.x, 1 B a side):

Build Hot side Cold side Duty Notes
Feed heater, one block (12.5 W/K) bleed steam, 2.4 bar (126 °C), condensate out through a trap feed water, 20 °C, ~5 g/s 1.0 kW feed out ~69 °C
Feed heater, 2 × 2 × 2 (100 W/K) the same steam feed water, 20 °C, ~10 g/s 3.9 kW feed out ~113 °C, 12 K under the steam
Cooler, 2 × 2 × 4 (200 W/K), counterflow hot water 90 °C, 23 g/s cooling water 20 °C, 23 g/s 4.3 kW hot out ~45 °C, cooling out ~65 °C
The same, both streams in at one end 3.3 kW a quarter less; hot out 56 °C, cooling out 54 °C
The same, cooling outlet left off 0.4 kW, falling its standing water has warmed to ~85 °C
Steam raiser 2 × 2 × 2 on a gas turbine's exhaust exhaust 500 °C water boiling at 14 bar 10.9 kW 92 % of what the exhaust could give
Reheater 2 × 2 × 4 live steam 18 bar, condensing crossover steam 2.4 bar, 44 g/s 6.5 kW crossover 126 → 198 °C

A good counterflow exchanger can send the cold stream out hotter than the hot stream leaves. In the cooler above the cooling water leaves at 65 °C while the hot water leaves at 45 °C. If your cold outlet is colder than your hot outlet, the streams are probably running the same way.

Rules of thumb:

Builds

Combined cycle: a gas turbine's exhaust raises steam

This is what the exchanger is for. A gas turbine throws away about 70 % of its fuel as exhaust at 500 °C. Two 2 × 2 × 2 exchangers turn part of that into steam for a steam turbine.

  1. Exhaust path (side A): gas turbine exhaust into the raiser's A at the back, out at its front, through a pipe into the economizer's A at the back, and out of its front to the air.
  2. Water path (side B), the other way: the feed pump (about 16 bar) into the economizer's B at the front (where the exhaust leaves, coolest), out at its back, through a throttle valve, into the raiser's B at its front.
  3. Steam: off the raiser's B at the back, top row, into a separator tank, and from its top to a steam turbine (the test used an HP shaft turbine and generator).
  4. Two controls: * Level: the raiser's water side holds only 8 B, about a minute of steaming. The feed valve must follow its level: open more as it drops, less as it rises. * Pressure: the steam turbine's throttle holds the raiser at about 14 bar. Wide open, the pressure falls and each kg of steam does less work.

Measured, the turbine burning 26.1 kW of fuel for 7.5 kW of shaft power (28.8 %):

Condensate reheat in a small plant

For a boiler and a 230V Steam Turbine with a Steam Condenser: the condenser hands back its water at about 35 °C, and the boiler spends fuel heating it again. Heat it with the furnace's flue instead.

  1. Water (side A): the condenser's pump outlet into the exchanger's A at the back, out of its front into the boiler's feed flange. A 2 × 2 × 1 (50 W/K) is plenty.
  2. Flue (side B): a pipe from the furnace's flue flange into B at the front, out at the back to a chimney or the air.
  3. The turbine's throttle holds the boiler pressure (8 bar in the test).

Measured, two such plants side by side, each boiler fired at the same 12 kW (a furnace's share; its flue carries about 5.3 kW over the ambient at 300 °C):

Common mistakes

Back to the reference